ge5506435780520622409
1
Carsales Staff26 Dec 2008
NEWS

Manufacturer of the year

Which manufacturer rattled your cage in 2008? The Carsales Network's editorial team had quite different opinions

2008: the auto year that was

Locally, more and more carmakers fight for your attention and car-buying dollar -- this year coming they'll be 50 of 'em! Which one of the throng caught your eye -- for good reason or bad? Which manufacturer pleased you or had you punching the wall in frustration?

Just as we do every year, the Carsales Network editorial team interacted with the full spectrum of car marques in 2008 -- everything from driving their finished products to quizzing their engineers, designers and execs...

So, who do we think deserves the title of manufacturer of the year? Our opinions were varied...

Mike Sinclair
Editor in Chief

BMW: Yes, I can hear the moaners now... Elitist, Euro lover -- blah, blah, blah... BMW might have its knockers, but when it comes to applying technology to afford real world efficiency solutions, even serial pests have to admit the company has delivered. The Bavarian's latest diesel engines are efficient and accelerative and are delivering executive-sized luxury saloons with hatchback fuel economy. Meantime, the company's direct-inject petrol engines are as good as spark ignition engines can get in terms of bang per gram of fuel. And now there's a significant part of the design world that's saying Bangle was right all along! BMW is entering a vintage period in this writer's opinion -- a perfect storm of technology, tactility, styling and substance. A city car or a supercar -- this is the one brand that can credibly deliver both...  

Ken Gratton
News Editor

Ford Australia: Last year, I settled on Mitsubishi Australia because of their gravity-defying ability to continue producing the 380 locally [Ed: the kiss of death?].This year, I'm expecting to be a bit more prescient in saying that Ford, a company that continues to be kicked in the goolies for lacklustre sales of its Falcon, will maintain a manufacturing presence in Australia -- supported by the Focus -- and will provide the sophisticated R&D backroom magic the head office needs for such projects as the T6 LCV, the Indian B-Car and (hopefully) new Falcons and Territorys.

Despite the tears of terror on behalf of the Blue Oval, the company still has a strong future ahead of it, but in Australia that future might be more about exporting intellectual property than finished products.

Melissa McCormick
Production Editor

Hyundai-Kia: Last year the Korean conglomerate got my vote for company to watch in '08, and the companies didn't disappoint. While somewhat quiet in terms of product release to Australians, we did, however, see more diesel (in Sonata, Grandeur) and even peoplemover/commercial options from the flying H brand. And really, this was a year to stay conservative.

Euro-threatening diesel plans and show specials like the V8 Genesis Coupe prove Hyundai's got some exciting stuff in the offing, too. Hyundai also came to the green party this year with its Blue Drive program, declaring in November it was aiming to become "the most fuel-efficient maker on the planet"... In fact, also see 'Company to watch in 2009'.

Gautam Sharma
International Correspondent

Tata Motors: A no-brainer, in my book. In a year otherwise notable only for doom and gloom, India's Tata Motors posted a pair of significant milestones in contrasting fashions. On the one hand, it outlaid about $US2.3 billion in March to secure the iconic Jaguar and Land Rover premium brands from Ford. At the other end of the spectrum, Tata unveiled arguably the modern-day version of the VW Beetle -- the Nano -- conceived to put motoring within the grasp of the Indian masses.

The "one-lakh rupee" ($3100) car is a masterpiece of packaging ingenuity and it paves the way for rival offerings from the likes of Renault-Bajaj. The Nano seems the right car for these credit-crunched times, but time [Ed: and government funding?] will tell whether the Tata brains trust can make a solid business case for Jag and Landy.

John Wright
Buying Used Expert

Ford Australia: I have trouble distinguishing company from products, so on the basis of the FG Falcon, it has to be Ford Australia. The supporting cast of new Fiesta, Focus, Mondeo and Territory look good, too. (But it makes you wonder what Ford is doing in the US, doesn't it?)

Otto Insider
The Auto Industry's Angry (not-so) Young Man

Tesla: Having the nerve to offer a warmed over Lotus Elise that dumps the high-revving Toyota petrol engine and snickity-snick gearchange for an electric motor and single ratio, fed by an engine-bay full of laptop batteries (6831 in all, I know you wanted to know the number), is worthy of an award. Yet, more incredulously, they're charging the Poms ninety-two thousand pounds (c$225,000) for the privilege. Did I mention the batteries last just 60 months and cost thousands to replace?

Pricing quibbles aside, Tesla has actually done the job of bringing a sportscar to market that looks enough like an Elise to give it carpark cred, and sprightly performance to give it paddock parking cred, while at the same time qualifying as a zero emissions vehicle (ignoring the smokestacks at the point of electrical energy conversion). How's 0-100 km/h in under 4sec and a fast zap to 200km/h top speed, and 350km range, to fend off the gas guzzlers sound?

The lithium-ion batteries and engine add 450kg to the Elise's petite form, and take 14 hours for a full recharge, which could lead to a bad attack of static ownership, but good on ya's for getting off ya butts and doing something.

Want to know who we picked in 2007? Check out more here

Share this article
Written byCarsales Staff
See all articles
Our team of independent expert car reviewers and journalists
Meet the team
Stay up to dateBecome a carsales member and get the latest news, reviews and advice straight to your inbox.
Subscribe today
Disclaimer
Please see our Editorial Guidelines & Code of Ethics (including for more information about sponsored content and paid events). The information published on this website is of a general nature only and doesn’t consider your particular circumstances or needs.
Scan to download the carsales app
    DownloadAppCta
    AppStoreDownloadGooglePlayDownload
    Want more info? Here’s our app landing page App Store and the Apple logo are trademarks of Apple Inc. Google Play and the Google Play logo are trademarks of Google LLC.
    © carsales.com.au Pty Ltd 1999-2026
    In the spirit of reconciliation we acknowledge the Traditional Custodians of Country throughout Australia and their connections to land, sea and community. We pay our respect to their Elders past and present and extend that respect to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples today.