Your questions answered: What’s the best SUV for me?
Like many, many Australian new and used car buyers, Cathy is looking for SUV advice. We’re here to help…
Love them or loathe them, SUVs are here to stay.
Buyers mostly love them, but their rise in popularity has led to a diverse market with many different offerings.
How do you choose the right SUV for you? You could start by asking…
Question: My husband is about 200cm tall and is looking for your recommendation on a reliable small-medium SUV possibly. He currently has a 2000 VY Commodore which is heavy and hard to get in and out. He’s thinking about an SUV to give him the height he needs to get in and out of the car comfortably. On the other hand, I am about 162cm and looking for a replacement for my 2002 Toyota Echo sedan, which is the household runabout. I am looking for something not too big, zippy, economical for driving around town, shopping, to/from work etc. What would you recommend for the two of us? – Cathy M
Answer: People fall for the SUV myth when people like your husband should also consider great cars like the Skoda Superb, which is brilliant for space and great in so many ways. He needs to do a ‘test fit’ for SUVs and should probably start with the Kia Seltos and Hyundai Tucson. For you, a Suzuki Swift will do the job at a great price, and perhaps also take a look at the Hyundai Venue as a baby SUV.
Question: You have previously helped me buy a couple of cars. Now my son and his family are looking at replacing an old Ford Territory with a similar car. They want seven seats with lots of space and are looking at the Toyota Kluger, Mazda CX-9 or even a European car a couple of years old. – Joyce W
Answer: The Kluger trades on past glories, the Mazda CX-9 is good, but the benchmark for him are the all-new Hyundai Santa Fe and Kia Sorento – truly excellent seven-seaters, with the Kia ahead on value. After all, carsales has just named it as our Car of the Year.
Of course we recommend the Kia Sorento it was the 2020 carsales Car Of The Year
Question: We are thinking of buying a new or demonstrator vehicle to tow a caravan. The caravan is just over 1000kg, so not huge, and we are thinking of either a Mazda CX-5 or the Subaru Forester or Outback. – Robyn K
Answer: Not to get too technical, but I’m not a fan of the automatic transmission system in the Subaru models – it’s called CVT and many people think it sounds like old-fashioned clutch slip. So I would steer towards the Mazda CX-5. The Mazda also has a chunkier look and feel. You should also consider that your caravan could end up weighing substantially more than 1000kg when loaded, so double-check on that before you commit to your vehicle choice.
Question: I am thinking about the Toyota RAV4 and Honda CR-V. Which of these would you recommend and why? – Ross O
Answer: As a new car, the RAV4 is superior even though the CR-V is good, but there is a very long waiting list for the Toyota. Second-hand, the CR-V is a better choice because it is almost as good as the RAV but noticeably cheaper because you don’t pay the premium for something with a Toyota badge.
Question: Considering buying a new petrol 2020 Jeep Grand Cherokee Limited or a current Toyota Prado GXL with luxury pack. Have had a 2004 Prado GXL from new and have been extremely happy with it, but am pretty disappointed with current model’s interior and features. Are Toyota likely to update interior in near future? – Michael L
Answer: Nothing major coming from Toyota until trickle-down from the new 300 Series Toyota LandCruiser, and, in comparison, the Jeep Grand Cherokee definitely feels special. A few years back Jeep’s customer service was woeful but things are much improved now.
Everybody wants a LandCruiser
Question: Have you any information regarding the release of the new 2021 Hyundai i30 hatch with the 206kW engine and automatic? I have contacted numerous dealers and they have no idea when it may be available. Could you also advise the better option between a used BMW 140i or Audi S3, if there is no release date on the Hyundai? – Neil J
Answer: The news from Hyundai Australia is that the car you crave, the new i30 N, is due in May-June, so probably worth the wait. If not, I’d go for the Audi.
Question: I have a Volkswagen Golf R, a Mark 7 from 2016, and was just thinking if it’s worthwhile upgrading to the latest Golf R model. Is it much better? – Vince G
Answer: You don’t need to rush. Wait until the R version of Golf 8, which is not arriving until the very back end of 2021 [Ed: More likely 2022].
Tall people will find there's plenty of leg room in the Skoda Superb
Question: Your thoughts on the Audi Q2, model 2021 please. And its release date? – Terry O
Answer: I’m not a huge fan of the Q2, which is basically a cosmetic small-car tweak for people who crave the SUV style. The 2021 model is only a minor update, not a full model change, so you might get a good deal on a superseded car. The update should arrive in May.
Question: I have a Hyundai ix35 and I have done 26,000km since new, six years ago. Next service they want to change my brake fluid. Seems a bit over the top to me. What do you think? – Graham D
Answer: Brake fluid is hygroscopic, which means it absorbs water over time. That reduces the boiling point of the fluid and the efficiency of the brakes. After six years, regardless of distance covered, a fluid change is definitely a good idea. And it’s probably in the factory service schedule for your car, not just a suggestion from a mechanic.
Question: Just wondering your thoughts on a 2010-2011 Holden Cruze or similar Holden models, second-hand at $8000-$8500 with between 105,000 and 116,000km on the clock. How is the support around for Holden? I need a cheap car around the $8000 mark second-hand to do about 200km per day on open roads. – Lincoln R
Answer: Avoid the Cruze, please. Quality is patchy. With your budget, get a Hyundai i30.
Find more of Your Questions Answered by carsales here
Tags
Mazda
CX-9
Car Advice
Selling A Car
Buying a Used Car
Your questions answered
Written byPaul Gover
Our team of independent expert car reviewers and journalists
Disclaimer Please see our Editorial Guidelines & Code of Ethics (including for more information about sponsored content and paid events). The information published on this website is of a general nature only and doesn’t consider your particular circumstances or needs.
In the spirit of reconciliation we acknowledge the Traditional Custodians of Country throughout
Australia and their connections to land, sea and community. We pay our respect to their Elders past and
present and extend that respect to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples today.